DLALISA INSIGHTS / GRAP 109 / PRINCIPAL–AGENT ARRANGEMENTS
GRAP 109: Can an Expired Agreement Still Be a Binding Arrangement?

A public-sector agreement reaches its expiry date. No written extension or addendum is signed. Nevertheless, both parties continue to exercise the rights and perform the obligations previously established. Does the absence of a current signed agreement mean there can be no binding arrangement under GRAP 109?
Not necessarily. The Standard of GRAP on Accounting by Principals and Agents (GRAP 109) recognises that binding arrangements are not confined to written contracts. Depending on the facts and applicable law, continuing conduct may support the existence of a tacit contract or another binding arrangement. The appropriate response is an evidence-based assessment—not an automatic conclusion that the former agreement remains in force.
Where a written agreement has expired but the parties continue performing, management should assess whether an enforceable tacit contract or another binding arrangement arose, obtain legal input on its validity and authority, and evaluate the resulting rights and obligations under GRAP 109.
Performance continues after the agreement expires
A public institution appointed another entity to implement projects involving suppliers and contractors. Their written implementation agreement expired on 30 June, and neither party signed an addendum. After that date, the implementing entity continued managing contracts with third parties and reporting expenditure; the commissioning institution continued approving deliverables, providing funding and receiving project reports. Both parties acted broadly in accordance with the former arrangement. The issue is whether those post-expiry actions created or evidenced enforceable obligations—and whether their continued activities still qualify as a principal–agent arrangement.
What GRAP 109 means by a binding arrangement
GRAP 109 paragraph .05 defines a binding arrangement by reference to rights and obligations that are enforceable against the parties, including rights arising from contracts or other legal sources. Its wording encompasses arrangements that operate as legally enforceable commitments even where their legal form is not a conventional signed contract.
Paragraph .05A explains that a binding arrangement may be evidenced by a contract; by legislation, regulations, lawful policies or decisions of authorised public-sector structures; or by the operation of law, including common law. It also expressly recognises that a binding arrangement is not invariably documented in writing.
Paragraph .20 addresses the particular difficulty of identifying binding arrangements in the public sector. It contemplates that, where other identified legal or documentary bases do not apply, a pattern of past actions could give rise to an arrangement for GRAP 109 purposes when the parties have, over time, no realistic alternative but to act in a particular way. This is a demanding factual assessment; it is not permission to disregard statutory requirements.
Consequently, the relevant question after expiry is not limited to whether an addendum exists. It is what enforceable rights and obligations, if any, existed during the period after expiry, and on what lawful basis.
What is a tacit contract?
Under South African contract law, a tacit contract is an agreement inferred from the parties’ conduct and the surrounding circumstances rather than expressly concluded in spoken or written terms. The evidence must support the inference that the parties intended to contract, agreed on sufficiently definite terms and created obligations capable of legal enforcement.
South African courts consider the proved conduct and circumstances as a whole. Consistent performance, acceptance of services, requests for continued work, approved payments and regular instructions may be relevant evidence. None is conclusive in isolation. In particular, an entity’s silence, the exchange of invoices or the fact that services continued does not automatically demonstrate the necessary agreement.
An alleged tacit contract after expiry must also be distinguished from an extension of the original contract. Depending on the wording of the former agreement and the facts, the parties may have entered into a new implied agreement on some or all of the former terms. The old terms may assist in interpreting the parties’ conduct, but do not necessarily carry over by default. Requirements for written renewal, valid authorisation and procurement compliance must be investigated.
Binding arrangement versus tacit contract
The concepts overlap, but they are not interchangeable. A tacit contract is one possible legal source of enforceable rights and obligations; a GRAP 109 binding arrangement is the broader accounting concept used when evaluating whether the principal–agent definition is met.
| Issue | GRAP 109 binding arrangement | Tacit contract in South African law |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | An arrangement that confers enforceable rights and obligations relevant to the accounting assessment. | A contract inferred from conduct showing agreement on enforceable terms. |
| Source | May arise from written or other contracts, legislation, authorised decisions, common law or qualifying conduct considered under GRAP 109. | Arises from an inference of contractual consensus based on what parties said and did, considered in context. |
| Evidence | Identify the parties, transactions, legal or other basis, rights and obligations and whether they remain binding. | Establish sufficiently clear conduct, agreement on ascertainable terms, legal capacity and a lawful basis for enforcement. |
| Relationship | Not every binding arrangement is a tacit contract. | A valid and enforceable tacit contract may qualify as one type of GRAP 109 binding arrangement. |
| Further GRAP test | Requires a separate assessment of the agent’s transactions with third parties on behalf of and for the principal’s benefit. | Its existence alone does not prove that either party acts as a principal or agent for accounting purposes. |
The key connection is enforceability. Where a tacit contract is legally established and enforceable, the resulting mutual rights and obligations can meet the GRAP 109 binding-arrangement definition. However, the standard does not convert conduct that is legally unauthorised or unenforceable into a valid public-sector contract.
How to assess the expired agreement in practice
We recommend a joint accounting and legal assessment, documented for the reporting period. The following questions should guide management’s conclusion.
01. Confirm exactly what expired
Review the original agreement, expiry date, termination and renewal clauses, restrictions on amendments, survival provisions, delegations and any subsequent approvals. Determine whether particular rights or obligations expressly survived expiry and whether another existing legal instrument remained operative.
02. Establish the parties’ post-expiry conduct
Prepare a dated chronology of instructions, correspondence, approved budgets, funding transfers, delivered work, accepted reports, invoices, payments and transactions with third parties. Identify evidence from both parties—not only internal records of one institution—and distinguish actual agreement from unilateral action.
03. Determine whether enforceable terms can be identified
Consider whether the evidence supports consensus on scope, duration, remuneration or reimbursement, decision-making authority, risk allocation and performance obligations. Assess whether the former agreement supplies evidential context for a new tacit arrangement. Obtain legal advice on whether these matters establish an enforceable contract or other legal rights.
04. Test lawful authority and compliance
Determine whether relevant officials or governing structures could lawfully bind the institution. Review applicable enabling legislation, delegations, the PFMA or MFMA as relevant, procurement requirements, Treasury instructions and any prescribed writing or approval formalities. An inference of agreement does not cure unlawful procurement or lack of authority.
05. Apply the complete principal–agent definition
If a binding arrangement exists, determine whether one entity was directed to undertake transactions with third parties on behalf of and for the benefit of the other. Assess the actual rights and obligations rather than job titles or descriptions such as “implementing agent”. Under GRAP 109, the absence of a binding arrangement or transactions with third parties is critical to the classification.
06. Document the reporting conclusion and regularise arrangements
Record the evidence, legal conclusion, GRAP 109 assessment, post-expiry accounting treatment and necessary disclosures. If rights or obligations changed, reassess the parties’ roles under paragraphs .22–.23. Resolve uncertainty prospectively through properly authorised documentation; do not use a backdated addendum to conceal a gap or non-compliance.
An essential public-sector legal safeguard
The possibility of a tacit contract is not a substitute for statutory compliance. In Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality v Metgovis (Pty) Ltd [2019] ZACC 9, the Constitutional Court discussed tacit contracts after an expired municipal agreement and confirmed that a tacit contract contrary to section 217 of the Constitution or applicable procurement legislation is unlawful and ordinarily void from inception. It dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction; it did not give blanket approval to tacit procurement extensions. Later public-sector procurement decisions likewise emphasise that conduct and payments cannot override mandatory lawful contracting requirements. The legal assessment must therefore precede any assertion that a tacit contract is enforceable.
Accounting implications when the parties kept performing
If a valid binding arrangement is established, the entity should identify the post-expiry period it covers and consider whether the principal–agent assessment remains the same as before. GRAP 109 addresses which party recognises the transactions, resources and obligations resulting from arrangements with third parties, and requires disclosures about the arrangement, significant terms and relevant professional judgements.
If a binding arrangement cannot be established, management should not retain the principal–agent classification merely because the former written agreement once existed. The underlying transactions, expenses, assets, liabilities and any disputes still require separate accounting assessment under the applicable Standards of GRAP and legal facts. The non-existence of a GRAP 109 principal–agent arrangement does not mean that transactions disappear from the accounts.
Our recommendation
Where an agreement has expired without a formal addendum but both institutions continue exercising rights and fulfilling obligations, expressly evaluate whether their conduct gave rise to a tacit contract. This is a defensible line of enquiry under the broad GRAP 109 definition, particularly when supported by an established course of dealings and clear mutual obligations.
The recommendation is to consider and substantiate the possibility, not to presume that an implied contract exists. Analyse alternative legal sources, seek a reasoned legal assessment of enforceability and authority, and then perform the distinct GRAP 109 principal–agent evaluation. That produces a more robust audit position than either asserting an automatic renewal or dismissing the relationship solely because the signatures on an addendum are missing.
How Dlalisa Incorporated can assist
We support public entities with technical GRAP reporting assessments, analysis of principal–agent relationships, review of financial-statement disclosures and the compilation of evidence-based accounting position papers. Matters involving contract validity, public procurement or legal enforceability should be addressed alongside suitably qualified legal advisers.
Primary sources and further reading
Accounting Standards Board — GRAP 109, Accounting by Principals and Agents (current versions). Refer particularly to paragraphs .05, .05A, .09–.12, .17–.23 and the disclosure requirements.
Accounting Standards Board — Identifying principal–agent arrangements: substance over form.
Constitutional Court — Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality v Metgovis (Pty) Ltd [2019] ZACC 9, especially paragraphs 24–30.
High Court — SMEC South Africa (Pty) Ltd v Johannesburg Market SOC Ltd [2026] ZAGPJHC 908, on public-procurement formalities and the limits of tacit conduct.
This article provides general technical commentary. It is not a legal opinion on any particular expired contract, an official ASB interpretation, or a guarantee of a particular accounting or audit outcome. Any real case requires review of its original terms, subsequent conduct and applicable legal framework.
